Amazing state India is..
Last week i heard the following three news:
1. A fake encounter scam in which a person of a minority community was killed in one of India's richest and highly Hindu governed state.
2. In the same indian state,a leading Indian political weekely-India Today in its April,23rd 2007 issue covers a district which has shown exemplary communal harmony ,where both the majority and minority communities assemble together in a worshipping platoform of a saint and recite Sufi Qawwalis and Bhagvad Geeta.
3. The chief minister of one of india's southern most state known primarily for its Anti-Hindi rhetoric goes for an election campaign in North India and delivers a speech in Hindi.
You must be wondering --So what has this to do with me and you?
It has...
It is this 'India' which has confused all the leading India centric socio-political intellegentsia across the world.They wonder how come a country with such a diverse demography, a country which is plagued by the politics of caste and religion, a country with deep rooted corruption is making waves across the world for its economic growth and is poised to become the third largest economy by 2020.
With my limited to exposure to literature pertinent to such an issue, i too was unanswerable and was looking for a convincing answer.
Finally i got one to a large extent in Edward Luce's book "Inspite of the Gods-The strange rise of Modern India"
Luce gives a good analogy.He says India is like a big truck with 10-12 big tyres,so even if couple of them goes flat the truck keeps on moving or like a group of honey bees who individually keep on flying in erratic direction but when seen as a whole bunch will always be moving in a single direction.He goes on to say that the fact that india is so demographically diverse helps it inadvertantly in non-proliferation of communal / anti-social incidents in other parts of the country. A very good example can be the gujarat riots which was luckily confined to with in the boundaries of that state.States like UP and Bihar with a much higher concentration of minorities remained peaceful under complete law and order.
It also reflects the patient and absorbing character indians have developed in due course of centuries. Had it been an extremely homogenous society like china,wonder what would have happend in india with these events having the high propensity of conflagration into the neighbouring states.
Having said all this and appreciating india's diverse character i strongly condemn whatever happend in Gujarat or the first bulleted point in this post.
Labels: Politics
